International Students
Face Broken Dreams

By Melissa Hankins

From The Wall Street
Journal
When Beatrix Vagacs, a 26-year-old Hungarian, was admitted to the
M.B.A. program at the State University of New York at
Binghamton two years ago, it seemed to her like a dream
come true. Ms. Vagacs, a former manager at a Budapest
technology company, desperately wanted to live in the U.S.
and to work in management consulting. She thought her
degree would clinch the deal.
When the time came to land a job, however, Ms. Vagacs
was shocked to learn that an M.B.A. isn't necessarily a
ticket to success. She expected to earn at least $80,000
as a newly minted M.B.A., but she has already been turned
down for positions three times because she isn't a U.S.
citizen. Every consulting firm that has interviewed her,
she says, wants to hire her for about $20,000 a year and
send her back to Budapest.
"I thought it would be much easier to get a job here
than it has been," she says. "So did many of my foreign
classmates. People are having a lot of trouble." With her
May 20 graduation fast approaching, Ms. Vagacs gave up
hope of staying in the U.S. Instead, she'll be doing
research for a university in Japan -- a far cry from her
original expectations.
Foreign students are pouring into U.S. business schools
in steadily increasing numbers to earn a prized American
M.B.A. degree and the big salary it usually fetches. After
getting a taste of life in the U.S., students like Ms.
Vagacs crave jobs that will prolong their stay.
But recruiters aren't exactly beating down their
dorm-room doors. In fact, some business schools say nearly
half of the recruiters that visit their campuses flatly
refuse to meet international students. And Ray Palmer, the
M.B.A. placement director at the University of
Connecticut, says that a hiring manger for a
financial-services company once told him: "My policy is,
if I can't pronounce the name, I throw the resume away."
Companies complain that foreign M.B.A. students often
lack knowledge of U.S. culture and fluency in English. But
the onerous visa process is the major reason that
companies resist hiring them. Within 12 months of
graduation, foreign nationals must be sponsored by a
company for an H-1B visa to stay in the U.S. But the
government will issue a maximum of only 195,000 such visas
a year.
Most companies won't discuss their policies on hiring
foreign nationals. But one that will, Eastman Kodak Co.,
says through a spokesman, "We do not recruit foreign
students or hire aliens because it could take time to get
them on board."
Schools Benefit
Even so, most business schools still actively recruit
foreign students. "The business world today is very much a
global village," says Don Martin, the University of
Chicago's associate dean of enrollment. "It's important
for domestic students to know how to interact in an
environment that doesn't revolve around one culture."
Foreign students also are a good revenue source for the
schools. Many don't have access to all the scholarships
that domestic students can qualify for, so they end up
paying full tuition. What's more, some schools want to
improve their reputations by raising the average GMAT
score of their applicants, and foreign students often
perform quite well on the standardized business-school
entrance exam.
Daniel Smith, chairman of the M.B.A. program at Indiana
University, says, "Foreign students are a dilemma for us
because they're so hard to place. We get very good
applicants, especially from Asia, but they want to stay in
the U.S." The trouble is "the government only has so many
visas to give," Mr. Smith says, "and companies are using
them up for their research and technology side rather than
their business side."
Despite their placement problems, Indiana, along with
such schools as the University of Chicago, Dartmouth
College and the University of Maryland, are seeing an
increase in foreign applications and enrollment. Last
year, Kenan-Flagler Business School at the University of
North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where the student body is
one-third international, saw its foreign applications
surge 85% from the 1998-99 academic year, compared with a
27% increase for U.S. students.
While many business schools say international students
represent about a third of their enrollment, foreign
students outnumber U.S. citizens at a few M.B.A. programs.
The business school at Clark University in Worcester,
Mass., has 70% foreign enrollment. Yet only 49% of the
foreign students were offered U.S.-based jobs by shortly
after graduation last year, compared with 100% of the U.S.
students.
Some business schools are trying to make their foreign
nationals more marketable. Dennis Grindle, the
career-management director at the Cox School of Business
at Southern Methodist University, guides them through a
series of seminars on visa issues, personal image,
etiquette and networking. SMU also helps some foreign
nationals with "accent modification" and communication
skills. "We teach them ŒHow to Americanize yourself
without losing your heritage,'" Mr. Grindle says.
Mr. Grindle also has formed an international job club
on campus where students meet for "accountability, support
and job-search leads." He says members must bring in job
leads each week -- three for the group at large and two
for themselves. Mr. Grindle himself promises to show up
with as many leads as each student brings. The
personalized attention definitely seems to help: All but
two of SMU's 19 foreign M.B.A. students found jobs in the
U.S. last year.
Some foreign nationals wouldn't mind going back home,
but they simply can't afford to return. Siti Syahwali, a
graduating Indiana University student, is perfectly
willing to work in Indonesia. But she wonders how she
could ever repay education loans when all her M.B.A. will
earn in Jakarta is $11,000 a year. A big oil company
wanted her to be a financial analyst in its Indonesian
operations, she says, but she sat before company officials
in shock when they offered her $11,000. She says she
didn't make any objections at the time because "she wasn't
raised to act like that." But like Ms. Vagacs, she was
expecting about $80,000.
"It's not decent," Ms. Syahwali says. "It doesn't
reflect my American schooling. I would like to be paid
according to my education." With the amount of money she's
been offered, she says, it would take her more than 50
years to pay off her education debt.
"A lot of American companies would like to hire non-U.S.
nationals for their global operations," says Maury Hanigan,
who runs her own consulting firm in New York. "But if they
pay them on a U.S. scale, they may make more money than
their [local] managers, and that could throw the company
into turmoil."
Some companies are becoming a bit more flexible. Bill
Ziegler, global director of recruiting for Accenture, the
management-consulting firm formerly known as Andersen
Consulting, reports a slight increase in his company's
recent hiring of international students. And he expects
the number to grow. The global economy will give Accenture
"even more reasons to look across country borders for
candidates," Mr. Ziegler says.
Some Exceptions
Sometimes companies ignore their own policies against
interviewing foreign M.B.A. students. Farhad Divecha, a
charismatic 24-year-old University of Illinois student
from Bombay, says he was crushed during his interview with
recruiters from agribusiness giant Cargill Inc. When the
recruiters discovered he wasn't a citizen, he says, they
abruptly cut the meeting short. Afterward, Mr. Divecha
told his French roommate, who was also interviewing with
Cargill, to tell recruiters he would help pay for his own
visa. His roommate got the job, he says.
"I know now that there can't be a corporate policy on
hiring foreign students that can't be broken," Mr. Divecha
says. Cargill didn't return phone calls seeking comment.
Mr. Divecha's experience with Cargill isn't uncommon,
says Mr. Palmer, the M.B.A. placement director at the
University of Connecticut. He advises students to try and
try again. Companies will often drop their restrictions on
hiring foreign nationals, Mr. Palmer says, if an
impressive candidate is persistent enough to nail down an
interview.
And remember that pronunciation-challenged
financial-services recruiter? Mr. Palmer says even he
ended up hiring a Chinese UConn student -- one whose last
name surely left him tongue-tied.
-- Ms. Hankins is a reporting
assistant for The Wall Street Journal in New York.